Once again, my point isn’t “don’t fix U.S. healthcare”…but rather, “be careful what you wish for”.

Walter Reed Army Medical Center isn’t part of the VA. The scandals surrounding Walter Reed have more to do with the fact that it is severely over burdened with the never ending war in Iraq and less to do with the fact that it’s not a profit driven entity.

Advancements in battlefield medicine have resulted in a substantial drop in mortality rates. Wounds that were once always fatal now more and more instead result in injury. This puts a much higher burden on the existing military health care system. The system hasn’t kept up.

People don’t necessarily need to experience something first hand to know it’s not a good thing. I’ve never walked through the desert with no water…but I know it’s not a good thing.

I don’t think I need to experience socialized medicine to know its serious drawbacks. There’s enough information out there for people to read and compare and make up their own mind. Myself, I’ve come to the conclusion that socialized medicine isn’t the solution to our problem….others still pine for that particular utopia.

Just as they will pine for the better health care that wealthier people can afford once government healthcare inevitably kicks in here.

“Socialist Argentina?”
“Socialist Australia?”
“Socialist Japan?”

It would do your cause a world of good to have some first-hand experience in the matter, Mark. Next you’re going to say, “America’s cell phone technology is more advanced than South Korea’s. I mean, I’ve heard.”

Yes, that would surprise me.
“Mark, if our health care system is really so great, why are so many Americans unhealthy when compared to the rest of the world?”

You can have the greatest healthcare in the next five galaxies and it won’t do your people any good if they don’t take care of themselves. There’s only so much Nanny Government can do to stop people from eating, smoking, drinking, drugging, and TV-watching themselves to death. Most of our chronic health problems stem from unhealthy or disfunctional lifestyles, and no amount of free healthcare can fill those black holes.

The solution to the rampant obesity in this country isn’t lack of access to healthcare….it’s putting down the #$% sandwich and taking a walk. Do we give up? Of course not. Does the healthcare/insurance racket need serious reform? You bet it does. Do hard working health care workers (my RN wife included) do the best they can despite all the complaining and caterwalling? You’d better believe it.

Is the answer replacing it all with government healthcare? God, no.

The next big scandal that will break in the next couple weeks is the shameful treatment of wounded soldiers and vets at the Walter Reed center. The VA, with its bloated beurocracy and terminal non-profit apathy, can be looked at as a sneak preview of what government run healthcare would look like. As admittedly maddening as our current system is, do you honestly think handing one-seventh of the national economy over to the government is the way to fix it?

The best health care I’ve ever had was when I was in the Air Force. It was a health care system managed by the government that managed to do a very good job. When I needed medical care, I got medical care. I didn’t have to write letters or get approval or jump through hoops. You would be surprised how efficient something can be when profit is not the motive.

Ranking nations’ healthcare: US isn’t No. 1 (Christian Science Monitor)
The article breaks various treatments into groups, where the United States naturally lags behind various other countries. But my point is that the overall healthcare of the United States is better than any other nation. Not a procedure here or a procedure there. In fact, according to the New York Times, “the Commonwealth Fund ranked the United States first in providing the “right care” for a given condition as defined by standard clinical guidelines and gave it especially high marks for preventive care, like Pap smears and mammograms to detect early-stage cancers, and blood tests and cholesterol checks for hypertensive patients. ”

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/12/opinion/12sun1.html

U.S. has second worst newborn death rate in modern world, report says (CNN)

Again, you’re transposing access to health care with quality levels of healthcare. The U.S. doesn’t have the second worst newborn death rate because the quality of the healthcare is compromised. Plus, the article stressed that mothers with lower educational attainment were associated with higher newborn mortality, which points more to the perpetual chaos and disfunction of that societal segment than the quality or access to our healthcare system.

Survey: Americans Rate U.S. Health Care Among Worst in Industrial World (FoxNews)

Here’s a telling excerpt from the article:

“But experts said the overall health picture for Americans is marked by inefficiency, duplication, and a lack of coordination that often leaves patients to navigate the system with little guidance from a doctor or other expert.”

Tell me…do you seriously think the federal government would be less inefficient and uncoordinated than the present system?

I agree there needs to be reform….but the “cure” of socialized medicine is far worse than the disease.

Let’s check in across the pond in the Socialist Havens of Europe to see how it’s working out for them:

http://society.guardian.co.uk/health/story/0,,2098276,00.html

http://www.postchronicle.com/news/breakingnews/article_21213573.shtml

http://www.manchesteronline.co.uk/personalfinance/s/133/133762_heart_patients_die_on_waiting_lists.html

http://www.lewrockwell.com/watson/watson13.html

etc, etc, etc, etc

Ranking nations’ healthcare: US isn’t No. 1 (Christian Science Monitor)

U.S. has second worst newborn death rate in modern world, report says (CNN)

Survey: Americans Rate U.S. Health Care Among Worst in Industrial World (FoxNews)

“Good” in what way? The actual quality of the health care itself or the access to it? Because if you’re talking quality, there’s absolutely no comparison between our system and socialized medicine’s. If you’ve got real information showing higher quality of medical care in a socialized (government run) system, I’d love to see it.